Posted by: Jim | June 13, 2008

Time To Purge Those Exaggerated Church Rolls

One of the resolutions passed this week at the SBC Annual Meeting was On Regenerate Church Membership. It calls on churches to maintain accurate membership rolls and remove from those rolls unregenerate or non-participating persons.

One of the problems in the SBC is that numbers on the rolls have, for years, been inaccurate and incorrect. For example, persons who ‘join’ the church are maintained on the rolls no matter what until they die. They can move away, drop out, take no part, and essentially disappear, and they are maintained on the lists as ‘members’. They can move from the community, join another Baptist church, and now their names are listed on two church rolls and they are counted twice (unless they ‘move their letter of membership’, which few do). Or, in other words, lots of people have memberships in two and sometimes three or more churches, meaning they are counted two or three or more times on the ‘official’ SBC lists.

Naturally all this results in false counts. There may be 16,000,000 people on the rolls as members of Southern Baptist Churches, but there is no doubt at all that the number is considerably less when it comes to actual individuals participating in their local church.

I am in complete agreement with the Resolution passed which states

WHEREAS, The ideal of a regenerate church membership has long been and remains a cherished Baptist principle, with Article VI of the Baptist Faith and Message describing the church as a “local congregation of baptized believers”; and

WHEREAS, A New Testament church is composed only of those who have been born again by the Holy Spirit through the preaching of the Word, becoming disciples of Jesus Christ, the local church’s only Lord, by grace through faith (John 3:5; Ephesians 2:8-9), which church practices believers’ only baptism by immersion (Matthew 28:16-20), and the Lord’s supper (Matthew 26:26-30); and

WHEREAS, Local associations, state conventions, and the Southern Baptist Convention compile statistics reported by the churches to make decisions for the future; and

WHEREAS, the 2007 Southern Baptist Convention annual Church Profiles indicate that there are 16,266,920 members in Southern Baptist churches; and

WHEREAS, Those same profiles indicate that only 6,148,868 of those members attend a primary worship service of their church in a typical week; and

WHEREAS, The Scriptures admonish us to exercise church discipline as we seek to restore any professed brother or sister in Christ who has strayed from the truth and is in sin (Matthew 18:15-35; Galatians 6:1); and now, therefore, be it

RESOLVED, That the messengers to the Southern Baptist Convention meeting in Indianapolis, Indiana, June 10-11, 2008, urge churches to maintain a regenerate membership by acknowledging the necessity of spiritual regeneration and Christ’s lordship for all members; and be it further

RESOLVED, That we humbly urge our churches to maintain accurate membership rolls for the purpose of fostering ministry and accountability among all members of the congregation; and be it further

RESOLVED, That we urge the churches of the Southern Baptist Convention to repent of the failure among us to live up to our professed commitment to regenerate church membership and any failure to obey Jesus Christ in the practice of lovingly correcting wayward church members (Matthew 18:15-18); and be it further

RESOLVED, That we humbly encourage denominational servants to support and encourage churches that seek to recover and implement our Savior’s teachings on church discipline, even if such efforts result in the reduction in the number of members that are reported in those churches, and be it finally

RESOLVED, That we humbly urge the churches of the Southern Baptist Convention and their pastors to implement a plan to minister to, counsel, and restore wayward church members based upon the commands and principles given in Scripture (Matthew 18:15-35; 2 Thessalonians 3:6-15; Galatians 6:1; James 5:19-20).


Responses

  1. There seems something odd here. First, there is an assumption that church leaders can know whether someone is regenerate or not, which is dubious but perhaps Baptist theology. Then there seems to be an assumption that those who have been added to church rolls because they have been judged in the past to be regenerate but are no longer attending church are not regenerate. It makes no sense to say that someone was regenerate and then is no longer regenerate. One can of course admit that they were previously wrongly judged regenerate, which goes back to my first point, or that despite being regenerate might not be saved, but one cannot say that they stop being regenerate. This whole thing really should have been put in terms of removing from church rolls those who are under church discipline, and applying that church discipline to those who stop attending church without good reason. Or else they should simply do what the Church of England does, which is start all church membership rolls from scratch every six years, with everyone having to reapply – and be automatically accepted if they are already members in good standing.

  2. It’s not so tough at all. Those who ‘bear the fruits of repentance’ – who publicly profess their faith, and who follow in baptism are termed, in traditional Baptist theology, as having the ‘marks of regeneration’. Those folk, and those alone, ought to be on church rolls.

    If they drop out, they have ‘excommunicated’ themselves. The point isn’t that they have ‘lost their salvation’ – the point is that they have failed to live up to their baptismal promise to live their confession. If they repent they can be restored and if not they will be adjudicated as non members.

    In short- membership doesn’t mean salvation- it is a mark of fidelity. Salvation is between the person and God.

    You’re not Baptist, are you?

  3. No, I’m not Baptist. OK, if “regenerate” means “having the marks of regeneration”, that makes sense. But it’s not what I have always understood “regenerate” to mean.

  4. What would be really interesting would be to get out and see how many Southern Baptist have any notion of what “church discipline” is.

  5. A subject near and dear to me and about which I have an essay pending with a particular publication. I’ll let you know when it’s out.


Categories